Both in Insurance

Safety Insurance Group vs United Fire Group

Over the past year SAFT returned +52.8% and UFCS returned +85.6%; their daily moves had a correlation of 0.33.

SAFT +52.8% UFCS +85.6%Growth of $1, one year, split-adjusted
MetricSAFTUFCS
Price$104.25$56.65
Market cap$1.53B$1.46B
Today+0.01%−0.75%
1 month+0.3%+3.7%
6 months+40.1%+42.2%
Year to date+33.8%+55.8%
1 year+51.7%+87.4%
Revenue growth (YoY)+3.0%+14.1%
Gross margin40.1%22.6%
Net margin10.6%8.7%
P/E (TTM)22.3×10.3×
Price / sales1.2×1.0×
Net cash$17.9M-$6.9M
Dividend yield3.53%1.41%
Volatility (60d)2.3%18.5%
Short % of float2.5%2.0%
Next earnings——

Shading marks the stronger figure where one clearly exists (lower is better for valuation and volatility).