Both in Insurance

MGIC Investment vs First American Financial

Over the past year MTG returned +3.3% and FAF returned +3.5%; their daily moves had a correlation of 0.45.

MTG +3.3% FAF +3.5%Growth of $1, one year, split-adjusted
MetricMTGFAF
Price$28.41$63.82
Market cap$5.83B$6.52B
Today−1.53%+0.16%
1 month+7.7%+3.8%
6 months+8.2%−6.9%
Year to date−2.8%+3.9%
1 year+7.8%+4.0%
Revenue growth (YoY)−2.9%+5.3%
Gross margin95.8%64.4%
Net margin61.7%8.5%
P/E (TTM)8.2×8.9×
Price / sales4.9×0.8×
Net cash-$431.8M$10.11B
Dividend yield2.39%3.82%
Volatility (60d)27.2%27.8%
Short % of float5.9%6.4%
Next earnings——

Shading marks the stronger figure where one clearly exists (lower is better for valuation and volatility).