Both in Insurance

American Financial Group vs Erie Indemnity Co

Over the past year AFG returned −6.1% and ERIE returned −31.1%; their daily moves had a correlation of 0.34.

AFG −6.1% ERIE −31.1%Growth of $1, one year, split-adjusted
MetricAFGERIE
Price$136.76$219.15
Market cap$11.34B$11.46B
Today−1.23%−1.47%
1 month−4.1%−14.2%
6 months+7.1%−12.8%
Year to date+0.1%−23.5%
1 year−5.4%−30.0%
Revenue growth (YoY)+5.5%+3.0%
Gross margin50.7%100.0%
Net margin12.2%16.2%
P/E (TTM)11.9×20.0×
Price / sales1.4×2.7×
Net cash-$383.0M$219.7M
Dividend yield2.57%2.67%
Volatility (60d)16.4%48.0%
Short % of float2.6%9.5%
Next earnings——

Shading marks the stronger figure where one clearly exists (lower is better for valuation and volatility).